| Home | About Us | Login/Register | Email News Tips |

A liberal dose of news, national and local politics, commentary, opinions and common sense conversation…

Rolling Stone Asks: The Worst President in History?

by Pamela Leavey

It’s no small surprise that so many of us think of George W. Bush as the worst president in history. The latest issue of Rolling Stone takes a look at this saying “Bush is in serious contention for the title of worst ever.”

In early 2004, an informal survey of 415 historians conducted by the nonpartisan History News Network found that eighty-one percent considered the Bush administration a “failure.” Among those who called Bush a success, many gave the president high marks only for his ability to mobilize public support and get Congress to go along with what one historian called the administration’s “pursuit of disastrous policies.” In fact, roughly one in ten of those who called Bush a success was being facetious, rating him only as the best president since Bill Clinton — a category in which Bush is the only contestant.

Among the reasons why the historians feel that Bush is the worst president in history is his “Credibility Gap”:

No previous president appears to have squandered the public’s trust more than Bush has. In the 1840s, President James Polk gained a reputation for deviousness over his alleged manufacturing of the war with Mexico and his supposedly covert pro-slavery views. Abraham Lincoln, then an Illinois congressman, virtually labeled Polk a liar when he called him, from the floor of the House, “a bewildered, confounded and miserably perplexed man” and denounced the war as “from beginning to end, the sheerest deception.” But the swift American victory in the war, Polk’s decision to stick by his pledge to serve only one term and his sudden death shortly after leaving office spared him the ignominy over slavery that befell his successors in the 1850s. With more than two years to go in Bush’s second term and no swift victory in sight, Bush’s reputation will probably have no such reprieve.

And, the ultimate test:

History may ultimately hold Bush in the greatest contempt for expanding the powers of the presidency beyond the limits laid down by the U.S. Constitution. There has always been a tension over the constitutional roles of the three branches of the federal government. The Framers intended as much, as part of the system of checks and balances they expected would minimize tyranny. When Andrew Jackson took drastic measures against the nation’s banking system, the Whig Senate censured him for conduct “dangerous to the liberties of the people.” During the Civil War, Abraham Lincoln’s emergency decisions to suspend habeas corpus while Congress was out of session in 1861 and 1862 has led some Americans, to this day, to regard him as a despot. Richard Nixon’s conduct of the war in Southeast Asia and his covert domestic-surveillance programs prompted Congress to pass new statutes regulating executive power.

The great read in Rolling Stone closes with a quote from a truly great president about the “judgments of history”:

“Fellow citizens, we cannot escape history,” said Abraham Lincoln. “We of this Congress and this administration, will be remembered in spite of ourselves. No personal significance, or insignificance, can spare one or another of us. The fiery trial through which we pass, will light us down, in honor or dishonor, to the latest generation.”

4 Responses to “Rolling Stone Asks: The Worst President in History?”

  1. That is about as thorough an examination of Bush’s failures as we could have at this point.

  2. This is from DCP

    Roddy McCorley at dailykos has outdone us all. In his own words:

    Well, it took me awhile, but I finally realized what “I’m the decider” reminds me of. It sounds like something a character in a Dr. Seuss book might say.

    So with apologies to the late Mr. Geisel, here is some idle speculation as to what else such a character might say:

    I’m the decider.
    I pick and I choose.
    I pick among whats.
    And choose among whos.

    And as I decide
    Each particular day
    The things I decide on
    All turn out that way.

    I decided on Freedom
    For all of Iraq.
    And now that we have it,
    I’m not looking back.

    I decided on tax cuts
    That just help the wealthy.
    And Medicare changes
    That aren’t really healthy.

    And parklands and wetlands
    Who needs all that stuff?
    I decided that none
    Would be more than enough!

    I decided that schools
    All in all are the best
    The less that they teach
    And the more that they test.

    I decided those wages
    You need to get by
    Are much better spent
    On some CEO guy.

    I decided your Wade
    Which was versing your Roe
    Is terribly awful
    And just has to go.

    I decided that levees
    Are not really needed.
    Now when hurricanes come
    They can come unimpeded.

    That old Constitution?
    Well, I have decided
    As”just goddam paper”
    It should be derided.

    I’ve decided gay marriage
    Is icky and weird.
    Above all other things,
    It’s the one to be feared.

    And Cheney and Rummy
    And Condi all know
    That I’m the Decider –
    They tell me it’s so.

    I’m the Decider
    So watch what you say
    Or I may decide
    To have you whisked away.

    Or I’ll tap your phones.
    Your e-mail I’ll read.
    `cause I’m the Decider –
    Like Jesus decreed.

    Yes, I’m the Decider
    The finest alive
    And I’m nuking Iran.
    Now watch this drive!

    Now that I think about it, Dr. Seuss anticipated this administration pretty well when he wrote Yertle the Turtle…

  3. I think even Geisel would like it.

  4. Yesterday, I was in “rare form” (as my Grandmother used to call it, LOL), and found myself following a woman out of the supermarket. Normal, right? The woman piled her groceries into her car, slammed the trunk and that’s when I saw the GWB sticker. Now, you all have no idea how close I came to walking up to her to ask her if she still supported the man (ie, nitwit). Praise be to Allah I had an ounce of self-control left and left her alone.

    But if I’d had a copy of the above… @;-)
    Thank you, Roddy McCorley, wherever you are.